South Park
Douche and Turd
Season: 8
Episode: 8
Air date: 2004-10-27
When PETA demonstrates against the use of a cow as South Park Elementary’s mascot, the student body is forced to choose a new one. As the election approaches, Kyle tries to convince everyone that his candidate, a giant douche, is better than Cartman’s nominee, a turd sandwich.
Stan: "Wait a minute, you didn't want me to vote, you wanted me to vote for your guy!"
It's kinda painful how relevant this episode is, even today. Gotta be honest, if my outsider perspective of American politics paints it as "Giant Douche vs. Turd Sandwich," that's not a good thing to be complacent about, accurate perspective or not (and going by the American comments and reviews of this episode, I'd say I'm more than half-right anyway).
Because just last year, in 2024, we had yet another presidential debate between former US president, Joe Biden and current president, Donald J. Trump, and it was a clown show full of aggressive rhetoric and what might as well be ad hominem, full of "you're despicable" instead of attacking the policies. I watched the debate hoping to be proven wrong, but it far surpassed my expectations, having the same kind of "You're a Turd Sandwich" absurdity that plagued our modern political discourse (especially in mainstream "journalism" like CNN and Fox News). The Kamala debate with Trump was a little better, less cross-talk and more focused on the policies from what little I could picked up (I didn't watch the whole thing), probably because they learned from the previous clown shows, but judging by the comments that mocked how much of an entertainment it still was, I probably missed all the good parts. Ah well.
Meanwhile, PETA is still around, 20 years after this episode aired. I don't know enough about them besides the claims of unethical and unnecessary euthanasia of animals, but I did see enough of their rhetoric to feel the hypocrisy of it all, not just the extremist views of animal rights over human ones. Singapore has SPCA, but it's less extreme and more like a pet adoption shelter, but our Singapore Zoo (which PETA would blindly protest against) is also more like a nature reserve, with documentaries featuring the zookeepers' close relationships with the animals, so take that as you will. I also support the notion that conservation is sometimes even necessary to prevent extinction and to protect endangered animals, so.
As for Diddy though? Racketeering, sex trafficking, allegations of sexual assault and grooming (including one Justin Bieber), not to mention all those "Freak Off" orgy parties of his. It's a whole laundry list of crimes, so the South Park parody of Diddy's "Vote or Die" campaign is far less absurd now than the actual reality.
I also particularly appreciate how Stan Marsh is usually the voice of reason centrist in all of this, just the Lisa Simpson of the show trapped in a town full of buffoons, and that includes Kyle the hypocrite who tried to gaslit Stan into voting for his party, a tactic you would see practiced by both sides of the political spectrum today. It always seemed absurd to me anyway how there's only two candidates for political elections, and how we always ended up griping about the flaws of both potential leaders but unwilling to do anything about the two-party system.
I would also like to take the chance to point out how I relate to Stan's centrist take, how you can't just see the flaws of both sides; you're forced to pick a side or you're painted as part of the problem. I consider myself a former liberal like Amala Ekpunobi, someone who voiced out against Trump's sexual harassment allegations and supported the "March for Our Lives" gun control movement after the '18 Parkland High school shooting, but sometime last year, I guess I just got fed up with all the performative vilifying from the left, disillusioned, if you will. That didn't mean I'm with those Turd Sandwich recaps either, but more leaning towards the party of rationality that doesn't subscribe to tribalism.
If anything, South Park (and Black Mirror) has proven this episode that reality is far more absurd than fiction, or as Jules Feiffer put it in 1959, "Satire doesn't stand a chance against reality anymore."